What Are the Highest-Quality Buttons? Button Materials Ranked

Polkom · 4 min read
What Are the Highest-Quality Buttons? Button Materials Ranked

The highest quality buttons are made from natural materials: real horn, mother-of-pearl (shell) and corozo. Close behind come well-made metal buttons in brass or zinc alloy. Urea and polyester are the best fit for volume garments, where consistency and price matter more than a natural look. Quality, however, is not just about the material. Edge finishing, thickness, hole drilling and colour fastness count too.

How button quality is judged

Before the ranking, here are the criteria professional buyers use to compare buttons:

  • Durability – does not crack during machine sewing, washing or ironing.
  • Look and feel – depth of colour, natural pattern, weight in the hand.
  • Finishing – smooth edge, polished holes without sharp edges that cut the thread.
  • Colour fastness – does not fade in washing or dry cleaning.
  • Batch consistency – the same size and thickness across every piece.

Button materials ranked

MaterialLookDurabilityCareClass
Real hornUnique pattern, warm and deep colourVery highWashable, no prolonged soakingLuxury
Mother-of-pearl (shell)Pearly lustre, cool to the touchHigh for thick buttonsNo bleach or harsh detergentsLuxury
CorozoMatt, natural look, takes dye wellHighGood; avoid long soakingPremium, sustainable
Metal (brass, zinc alloy)Relief, logo, finishesVery highGood, nickel-freePremium
Bone, wood, coconutNatural, rusticMedium to highWash with careUpper-mid
UreaSolid colour, stone and horn effectsHigh, iron-resistantVery goodMid, consistent
PolyesterAny colour and effectGoodVery goodMass market

1. Real horn

Real horn is the classic for high-end jackets, coats and knitwear. Every button has its own pattern, so no two are ever quite the same. The material is strong and warm to the touch. Horn buttons are the most expensive natural option, but also the most recognisable sign of quality on a coat.

2. Mother-of-pearl and shell

Mother-of-pearl gives a pearly lustre no plastic can match. That is why mother-of-pearl buttons are the standard on luxury shirts. The look depends on the shell. Trochus is denser, agoya is whiter and finer, and dark shell buttons give a grey to black sheen.

3. Corozo

Corozo is made from the tagua nut and is a natural, renewable material. It takes dye very well, so you can get almost any colour with a matt, natural look. Corozo buttons are the best choice when a brand wants both quality and sustainability.

4. Metal

Metal buttons in brass or zinc alloy are the most durable. They allow a raised logo, enamel and any finish. At Polkom all metal buttons are nickel-free. Quality shows in the weight, the crisp relief and the even plating.

5. Urea and polyester

Urea is a thermoset plastic. It does not melt under the iron and has a solid, refined look, so it is often used on suits and uniforms. Polyester is the most versatile material for colour and effects and is the standard in mass-market clothing. Both are an excellent choice when you need wash stability and consistency across a large run.

Luxury buttons for shirts

On a shirt the button is seen up close and fastened every day. That is why a luxury shirt almost always has mother-of-pearl buttons. What to look for:

  • Size – usually 16–18L for the front placket, 14–16L for collar and cuffs.
  • Thickness – a thicker mother-of-pearl button (around 3 mm or more) looks more expensive and is stronger.
  • Edge – polished, slightly rounded edge with no cloudy spots.
  • Holes – cleanly drilled so they do not cut the thread.

If the budget does not allow natural shell, polyester buttons with a pearl effect are a good alternative. You will find more styles for menswear in our men's buttons section.

The best buttons for coats and suits

For a coat, choose horn, corozo or a shank metal button in 32–40L. They cope with heavy fabric and frequent fastening. For a jacket or suit, the classic choice is a four-hole horn or corozo button, usually 32L on the front and 24L on the sleeves. Urea is a practical option for uniforms and suits that are pressed often. More on sizing in the article button sizes in lignes and millimetres.

Why quality buttons cost more

The price difference comes from the raw material and the handwork. Real horn and mother-of-pearl are sorted by colour and pattern, and a large share of the raw material is rejected. Corozo is dried for a long time before it is cut. Metal buttons need a die, polishing and electroplating. Polyester and urea production is more automated, so the price is lower on large runs. A good rule is that the button should match the class of the fabric. A cheap button on an expensive coat spoils the impression, while a luxury button on a mass-market T-shirt rarely pays off.

If you are unsure, order samples in two materials and sew them onto the collection fabric. The difference is usually obvious at once.

Polkom – manufacturer of buttons in every material

Polkom is a button manufacturer with over 30 years of experience. We offer buttons in horn, mother-of-pearl, corozo, metal, urea, polyester, wood and coconut, with your logo or dyed to a Pantone colour. All products are OEKO-TEX® certified and metal buttons are nickel-free. The minimum order is generally 1,000 pcs per model, and higher for some button models. Samples depend on the model, and production takes 10–20 days. Send a request for a quote or sample and we will help you choose the material.

Share this article

Direct from the manufacturer

Related products

Direct from the manufacturer – samples and production to your design, colour and logo

Request a quote Request a sample
Gallery

From our production

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

Which button material is the highest quality?
Real horn, mother-of-pearl and corozo are at the top for their look, strength and uniqueness. Metal buttons in brass or zinc alloy are the most durable. The best choice depends on the garment: mother-of-pearl for shirts, horn or corozo for jackets and coats, metal for denim and outerwear, urea for uniforms.
What buttons are used on luxury shirts?
Luxury shirts almost always have natural mother-of-pearl buttons, most often 16–18L on the front placket and 14–16L on the collar and cuffs. A thicker button with a polished edge and smooth holes is preferred. A more affordable alternative is polyester buttons with a pearl effect.
How can I tell whether a button is good quality?
Check the edge and the holes. They should be smooth, with no sharp edges that cut the thread. Buttons in a batch should be the same size and thickness, and the colour should not fade in washing. On metal, look for crisp relief and even plating. A sample is the surest test.
Are there sustainable buttons that are also high quality?
Yes. Corozo is a natural, renewable material with a premium look, and horn and mother-of-pearl are natural too. Polkom also offers recycled versions on inquiry and holds GRS certification. All products are OEKO-TEX® certified, and metal buttons are nickel-free.
Custom offer
Looking for a specific model, colour or size?

Send us an inquiry with a description or photo – you will receive an offer, samples and a production lead time.